Brief history of patentable subject matter rejections Ever since Alice/Mayo, a number of decisions have been rendered regarding patentable subject matter or 35 USC 101. In other words, whether a claim in a patent or patent application is eligible for patent protection under Section 101. Each new case adds to the body of patentable subject matter case law to help the … [Read more...]
Before filing a patent application
Before filing a patent application, among other activities, you must make sure that you own the patent rights, it is eligible for patent protection and also new and non-obvious. Browse related articles below.
Scriptpro LLC v. Innovation Associates, Inc. (Fed. Cir. 2016) is an opinion that provides pointers on how to write a patent application based on a few of the arguments that were presented by the defendant attempting to invalidate the patent, specifically, failure to satisfy the written description requirement. By anticipating these types of arguments, it may mitigate potential … [Read more...]
Electric Power Group, LLC v. Alstom, 830 F.3d 1350 (Fed. Cir. 2016) is another 35 USC §101 case dealing with patent eligible subject matter. The Court held that the claimed invention was ineligible for patent protection and thus invalid. The patent at issue (US Pat. Nos. 8060259 and 8401710) was directed to systems and methods for performing real-time performance monitoring of … [Read more...]
In GPNE Corp. v. Apple Inc. (Fed. Cir. August 1, 2016), the written description was presented in a way that narrowly described the invention, and thus the court ascribed a narrow meaning to the terms of the claims and found no patent infringement liability against the defendant. Although the claims define the metes and bounds of what is protected under a patent, the terms of … [Read more...]
The primary issue in MCRO, Inc. v. Bandai (Fed. Cir. September 13, 2016) patent eligible subject matter for a software invention. The Federal Circuit found a claim of a patented software invention was patent eligible subject matter. Given that for the past two years, relatively few software patents were affirmed as being eligible for patent protection (i.e., patent eligible … [Read more...]