• Home
  • About
    • Client Reviews
    • Patent Samples
    • Accolades
    • About Firm
    • Technologies
    • FAQs
  • Services
    • Patent
      • Utility Patents
      • Design Patents
      • Patent Application
      • Patent Defense
      • Patent Enforcement
      • Working with In-House Attorneys
    • Trademark
      • Trademark Search
      • Trademark Application
      • Trademark Enforcement
      • Trademark Defense
    • Licensing
    • Worldwide IP
    • Risk Management
    • Due Diligence
  • Industries
    • Browse Patent Samples
    • Automotive Patents
    • Construction Patents
    • Consumer Products Patents
    • Electronics Patents
    • Food, Beverage, & Other Culinary Patents
    • Manufacturing Patents
    • Medical Products & Devices Patents
    • Optics Patents
    • Software & App Patents
    • Tools & Equipment Patents
  • Learning Resources
    • First-Time Inventor?
    • Why Patent Your Invention in a Bad Economy?
    • Videos on Patents
    • Search 180+ Articles
      • Patent process
        • Overview of Patent Process
          • Patent process timeline and major milestones
          • Patent Process: Invention to Patent Granted (Simplified)
          • Patent process, overall steps and procedures
        • Overview of the examination process within the USPTO
          • Highs and lows of securing patent protection for your invention
          • What is the Patent Office procedure after filing a patent application?
        • Benefits of a Patent Search
          • What is a patent search and How to do it?
        • Patent attorneys, agents and the USPTO can help with the patent process
        • USPTO Website
      • Invention Agreements
        • What is an NDA and when to use them?
        • How to use a contract to protect your invention?
        • Working with others without losing your IP rights
        • Patent Assignments for Independent Contractors
        • Losing Invention Rights When Hiring or Collaborating with Others
        • Avoid Problems: Get an Invention Assignment Agreement
      • Protect Inventions
        • Misconceptions of Provisional Patent Applications
        • Do you need to get your patent attorney to sign an NDA?
        • Can a confidentiality agreement protect me like a patent application?
        • Four types of intellectual property to protect your idea and how to use them
          • Overview of Patents and Intellectual Property
          • Patent protection benefits and why every inventor should consider getting one
          • 8 tips to successfully protect your idea
          • Benefits of Patent Protection
          • Best uses for design patents
        • Reasons to only market your invention after securing patent pendency
          • Dangers of 1 yr grace period under first-inventor-to-file system
          • File a patent application before telling others about the invention
        • Risks and benefits of securing software patent protection
          • Strategy to overcome patentable subject matter rejection
        • Pros and cons of filing a continuation-in-part application
          • What is a continuation patent application?
      • How Patent Applications Work: the Basics
        • How to respond to an office action?
        • Request for non-publication of a patent application
        • Anatomy of a Patent Document
        • How to write a broad patent application?
        • Design patents: pros and cons
      • Patent costs
        • How much does it cost to get a utility patent?
        • Provisional Patent Application: Cheap Alternative?
        • Patent Cost Framework and cash flow
        • Provisional patent application: a cheap option?
        • Cheap provisional patent applications
      • Patent infringement
        • Basics of writing a patent claim for a patent application
        • Patent Marking: Everything you wanted to know
        • Avoiding Patent Infringement
        • Can I Copy My Competitor’s Product?
        • Can I Copy My Competitor’s Product? (Design Patent)
      • Worldwide patents
        • Pros and cons of securing worldwide patent protection and their steps
        • Foreign patent filing to secure protection in other countries
      • Responding to Office Actions
        • Overview of Office Actions
      • Trademarks
        • Trademark Registration: common law, state and federal
        • How to obtain a federal trademark registration?
        • How to select a trademark?
          • Protect your idea when pitching to an investor, potential licensee, or buyer
  • Schedule Consultation
  • Contact

Top-Rated Orange County Patent Lawyer | Helping Inventors in Orange County, Los Angeles County & Beyond | OC Patent Lawyer, Irvine CA

Orange County Patent Attorney

(949) 433-0900
You are here: Home / Patent application process / After Patent Grant / Patent license unenforceable because of nonpatent rights

Patent license unenforceable because of nonpatent rights

July 19, 2013 by James Yang

SpidermanPatents are viewed as a necessary evil in the United States.  Monopolies are considered evil in the United States but patent laws which have monopoly like characteristics are designed to promote the Sciences in that it gives inventors an exclusionary right (i.e., monopoly like right) for a limited period of time in exchange for the inventor’s disclosure of the invention to the public.  The government does not want to the power of the patent to influence the marketplace after the patent term has expired.

Based on the foregoing, any royalties collected as a result of the patent license must stop upon expiration of the patent term.  In contrast, royalties may be paid to the licensor indefinitely for non patent related rights such as trade secrets and know how licensing.  The problem comes when a patent license is extended to a licensee for patent as well as non patent related rights and the agreement dictates that the licensee will pay royalties to the licensor even after expiration of the patent.  If the royalty being paid after expiration of the patent is in fact a royalty on the patent, then the patent license is unenforceable even if a portion of the royalty payment is attributable to non-patent rights.  (e.g., trademark, know-how and trade secrets).

In Kimble v Marvel, Kimble approached Marvel with a spider man toy where kids could spread a web of string upon mimicking spider-man’s classic hand motion.  Marvel rejected Kimble’s idea but went on to market and manufacture a similar product.  At the time, Kimble had a pending patent application which later matured into a U.S. patent.

Kimble asserted the patent against Marvel.  During litigation, the parties settled the matter with Marvel agreeing to pay a royalty to Kimble.  The basis for the royalty payment was in part due to the patent and also a verbal agreement (i.e., contract claim) between Kimble and Marvel at the time of the disclosure.  When Kimble disclosed the toy idea to Marvel, they had a verbal agreement for Marvel to pay Kimble money should Marvel incorporate Kimble’s idea into a toy.  A part of the royalty was based on the verbal agreement.  A part of the royalty was due to the patent rights in Kimble’s issued patent.  The agreement between Kimble and Marvel required Marvel to pay Kimble royalties indefinitely even after expiration of the patent.  The royalty rate was the same before and after expiration of the patent.  As a result, the court concluded that the royalty collected after expiration of the patent must be attributed to the patent.  If so, the power of the patent is being leveraged even after expiration of the patent term.  Hence, the agreement was unenforceable.  Kimble could not reform or rewrite the agreement to collect a smaller royalty for the contract claim in an attempt to apportion out the royalties due to the patent.

The court reviewed prior case law on the subject and held that there should be a two tier royalty payment structure for the agreement to survive.  The two tiers must include different royalty rates for royalties for rights during patent rights and another royalty rate for rights surviving expiration of the patent.

The bottom line is that patent license agreements for patent and non patent related rights may cause the patent license agreement to be unenforceable for the part after expiration of patent term unless the royalties for the patent and non patent rights are clearly distinguishable in the royalty rate structure.

I invite you to contact me with your patent questions at (949) 433-0900 or [email protected] Please feel free to forward this article to your friends. As an Orange County Patent Attorney, I serve Orange County, Irvine, Los Angeles, San Diego and surrounding cities.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Author

James Yang is a patent attorney. For more than 16 years, James Yang has been representing clients to secure patent protection for their inventions and register trademarks to protect their brands. If you need help, call him at (949) 433-0900. Read More…

Popular Posts

  • Patent process overview
  • Patent process explained
  • How much does a patent cost?
  • Why patent your invention in a bad economy?

Patent Book

Navigating the Patent System - new book by Orange County patent attorney, James Yang

Navigating the Patent System: Learn the patent process and strategies to protect your invention

Read for Free
Buy at Amazon

RECEIVE PATENT ARTICLES

Stay up to date on major changes and get tips on the patent process.

We respect your privacy.

Popular Posts

Patent process overview
Patent process explained
How much does a patent cost?
Trademark process and costs
Patent process and costs

 

Services

Utility Patents
Design Patents
Patent Prosecution Services
Patent Defense Services
Patent-Law Counsel for In-House Attorneys
Trademark Prosecution Services
See All Services

Industries

Automotive Patents
Consumer Products Patents
Culinary Patents
Manufacturing Patents
Medical Patents
Optics Patents
Software & App Patents
See All Industries

Contact

James Yang
OC Patent Lawyer
2372 Morse Ave., Suite #178
Irvine, CA 92614
Tel: (949) 433-0900

Connect

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Sitemaps

Sitemap: Pages | Sitemap: Posts

Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

By accessing this blog, you agree that no attorney-client relationship is formed except by a subsequent written retainer agreement. Also, you agree to not send confidential information unless directed by me to do so. The information posted on this blog is legal information and not legal advice.
Complete Terms of Use
Complete Privacy Policy

ADA Compliance

OC Patent Lawyer aims to ensure that its services are accessible to people with disabilities.
Accessibility Statement

Service Area

From our office in Irvine, California, we serve clients from all areas within Orange County and Los Angeles County, California.

© 2023 · James Yang, Your Entrepreneur and Mid-Size Business Patent Attorney