Why innovation matters to Orange County?
Innovation matters to the local economy where innovation occurs. Innovation brings jobs and revenue to the local economy. We can see that innovation has helped develop new products that otherwise would not have been created. But for the incentive of a patent, many new drugs that have high research and development costs but are easy to copy once they are available to the public would not have been invented and brought to market. The patent data for Orange County, California shows that the top 2 innovative companies are in the fields of medical devices and pharmaceuticals. Patent protection also offers inventors and businesses the opportunity to secure new funding for startups and small businesses. New products and processes mean new businesses, more jobs, increased efficiencies, and more opportunities.
The data below focuses on the 4 most innovative OC companies. Why the top 4? The reason is that the number of patents for each company below the top 4 dropped off significantly compared to the top 4.
Source: USPTO filing and patent grant data
The companies in the top 4 are based on the number of patents issued to the companies for the year of 2017, according to data at the United States Patent & Trademark Office. The data below cover not only the number of patents issued, but also the top areas of innovation, the top innovators at those companies, and other statistics. The data show the relationship between the important areas of innovation in each company, as well as the more-prolific inventors in the company.
How far above “average” are OC’s top innovators?
The top 4 most innovative companies in Orange County were granted 66 patents on average in 2017. To put that into context, the average number of patents held by a company that received at least 1 patent in 2017 was 3.43 patents per company. Compared in those terms, the top 4 most innovative companies were granted about 19 times more patents than were granted “average” company that is granted patents.
Most companies in Orange County, California were not awarded even a single patent in 2017, because relatively few companies apply for patents at all. Based on 2016 Census data, there were 94,703 businesses in Orange County, California.1 Assuming that this statistic stayed roughly the same for 2017, only 471 companies were granted a patent in 2017. This means that only 0.5% of all Orange County companies were granted a patent in 2017.
What industries are the top innovators in?
The data below shows that the top innovators in Orange County, California invent in the areas of pharmaceuticals, medical devices, software, and electronics.
Which companies are the top innovators in Orange County?
The most innovative companies in Orange County, California are:
- Allergan, Inc.
- Broadcom Corp.
- Edwards Lifesciences Corp.
- Universal Electronics, Inc.
Allergan, Inc.
Allergan plc (NYSE:AGN) is a global pharmaceutical company. On its website, Allergan boasts commercial operations, manufacturing, and R&D in more than 100 countries. Although Allergan is headquartered in Dublin, Ireland, the company assigns most of its patents to Allergan, Inc., based in Irvine, California. A search of the USPTO database shows that the USPTO assigns a few patents to Allergan Industrie SAS in Pringy, France, and Allergan Pharmaceuticals International Limited or Allergan Holdings Unlimited Company, which are located in Dublin, Ireland.
The United States Patent and Trademark Office categorizes all ideas into 8 different sections, known as the Cooperative Patent Classifications (CPC). Each of these 8 different sections is further categorized into smaller subsections. The CPC sections are:
A: HUMAN NECESSITIES
B: PERFORMING OPERATIONS; TRANSPORTING
C: CHEMISTRY; METALLURGY
D: TEXTILES; PAPER
E: FIXED CONSTRUCTIONS
F: MECHANICAL ENGINEERING; LIGHTING; HEATING; WEAPONS; BLASTING
G: PHYSICS
H: ELECTRICITY
Table 1 below shows the number of patents granted to Allergan in each of the subsections of the CPC and their respective % with respect to the total number of patents granted to Allergan. This should give you a sense of their focus areas of innovation.
Top areas of innovation for Allergan
|
CPC Subsection Title |
Number of patents categorized in CPC section | % of the total number of patents |
| 49 |
62% |
|
| 23 |
29% |
|
| 3 |
4% |
|
| 1 | 1% | |
|
B01: Physical or Chemical Processes or Apparatus in General (e.g., furnaces, kilns, ovens) |
1 |
1% |
| A47: Furniture | 1 |
1% |
| Grand Total: | 79 |
|
Table 1
A patent will list the inventors that contributed to the invention. Collectively, they are known as inventive entities. At Allergan, an average of 2.3 inventors were listed on each patent granted.2 In a sense, this indicates the level of cooperation between departments and innovators within the company. A higher number might indicate a more collaborative environment between people in the R&D department of the company. A lower number might indicate that people in the R&D department work independently and in silos instead of collaboratively.
When the same inventor is listed on multiple documents, this may indicate that the individual is the main driver of innovation for the company, a group, or a particular technology within the company.
Table 2 lists the top 4 inventors based on the number of patents for which they were included as part of the inventive entity.
|
Inventor |
Number of Patents |
|
12 |
|
|
11 |
|
|
9 |
|
| Veena Viswanth |
9 |
Table 2
As noted above, Allergan was granted the most number of patents in CPC subsection A61. In particular, they were granted 49 patents in this subsection. A61 relates to Medical or Veterinary Science and Hygiene. To get a feel for the specific types of the invention in this subsection, the list below is a sampling of the Allergan patents in this section.
| 9763958 | Preservative free bimatoprost and timolol solutions |
| 9763959 | Compositions and methods for stimulating hair growth |
| 9764009 | Treatment of psychological trauma |
| 9765065 | Therapeutic substituted cyclopentane |
| 9775846 | Hypotensive lipid-containing biodegradable intraocular implants and related implants |
| 9775849 | Implants and methods for treating inflammation-mediated conditions of the eye |
| 9782492 | Stabilization of therapeutic agents to facilitate administration |
| 9782517 | Crosslinked hyaluronic acid-collagen gels for improving tissue graft viability and soft tissue augmentation |
| 9795615 | Methods for fat reduction |
Top Allergan inventors in CPC Subsection A61 are shown in Table 3.
|
Inventor |
Number of Patents |
|
6 |
|
|
5 |
Table 3
John E. Donello made both lists. He was named on the most number of patents and listed on the most number of patents within the primary area of innovation for Allergan. Moreover, although Chetan P. Pujara was not identified as a prolific inventor, Pujara is a prolific inventor within the primary area of innovation for Allergan.
Broadcom Corp.
In 2016, Broadcom Corp. (NASDAQ:AVGO) located in Irvine was merged with Avago Technologies located in San Jose, California. As such, the current patent assignment data for Broadcom appears to be the remains of the merger between Broadcom and Avago, and may not accurately reflect the total number of patents granted to Broadcom. Eventually, I suspect that Broadcom’s patent applications will eventually be assigned to Avago Technologies, not Broadcom. Just as an FYI, in 2017, Avago was granted 874 patents.
Broadcom primarily innovates in electric communication techniques. As shown in Table 4, They were awarded 53 patents in 2017 in this area of technology. This represents 64% of the total number of patents granted to Broadcom. This is aligned to their core business as a supplier of semiconductor technologies within four primary markets: wired infrastructure, wireless communications, enterprise storage, industrial, and others.
| CPC Subsection Title | Number of patents categorized in CPC section | % of the total number of patents |
| 53 |
64% |
|
| 8 |
10% |
|
| 6 |
7% |
|
|
H02: Generation: Conversion or Distribution of Electric Power |
4 |
5% |
|
4 |
5% |
|
|
Y02 |
2 |
2% |
| G10: Musical Instruments; Acoustics | 1 | 1% |
| G11: Information Storage | 1 | 1% |
| G02: Optics | 1 | 1% |
| G05: Controlling; Regulating | 1 | 1% |
| B60: Vehicles in General | 1 | 1% |
| A63: Sports; Games; Amusements | 1 | 1% |
| Grand Total: | 83 |
Table 4
On average, 2.3 inventors were listed on each patent.3 Broadcom and Allergan reflect the same level of teamwork to innovate between departments and innovators within the company.
Table 5 lists the top 3 inventors based on the number of patents for which they were included as part of the inventive entity.
| Inventor | Number of Patents |
| Xuemin Chen | 10 |
| Ahmadrez (Reza) Rofougaran | 6 |
| John Walley | 5 |
Table 5
As noted above, Broadcom was granted the most number of patents in CPC subsection H04. In particular, they were granted 53 patents in this subsection. H04 relates to Electric Communication Technique. To get a feel for the specific types of the invention in this subsection below is a sampling of the Broadcom patents in this section.
| 9537684 | Adaptive transmit beamforming for frequency division duplexing systems |
| 9538199 | Data transmission across independent streams |
| 9544074 | Time-shifting distribution of high definition audio data |
| 9544095 | Channel estimation for phase-only feedback and methods for use therewith |
| 9544117 | Adaptive reference signal mapping in wireless multi-access communication networks |
| 9544586 | Reducing motion compensation memory bandwidth through memory utilization |
| 9544638 | Method for reconstructing system time clock (STC) without carrying PCR |
| 9544665 | Providing multiple ABR streams using a single transcoder |
Top Broadcom inventors in CPC Subsection H04 are shown in Table 6.
| Inventor | Number of Patents |
| Xuemin Chen | 9 |
| Rajesh Shankarrao Mamidwar | 4 |
Table 6
Edwards Lifesciences Corp.
Edwards Lifesciences Corp. (NYSE: EW) is a global leader in patient-focused medical innovations for structural heart disease, as well as critical care and surgical monitoring.
Edwards Lifesciences innovates in the same technology area as Allergan because its primary area of innovation is in CPC Subsection A61, as shown in Table 7. However, it does not appear that the two companies are direct competitors. Moreover, Edwards Lifesciences is highly focused in its pursuit for patent protection. As shown in the table below, Edwards Lifesciences received 90% of its patents in the CPC Subsection A61, whereas Allergan received 62% of its patents in this area.
| CPC Subsection Title | Number of patents categorized in CPC section | % of total number of patents |
| A61: Medical or Veterinary Science; Hygiene | 44 | 90% |
| Not categorized | 4 | 8% |
| A01: Agriculture; Forestry; Animal Husbandry; Hunting, Trapping; Fishing | 1 | 2% |
| Grand Total: | 49 |
Table 7
On average, 2.5 inventors were listed on each patent.4 The data suggests that Edwards Lifesciences has the greatest level of cross-pollination of ideas between departments and innovators within the company compared to Broadcom and Allergan.
Table 8 lists the top 5 inventors based on the number of patents for which they were included as part of the inventive entity.
| Inventor | Number of Patents |
| Manouchehr A. Miraki | 5 |
| Scott Heneveld, Sr. | 4 |
| Louis A. Campbell | 4 |
Table 8
As noted above, Edwards Lifesciences was granted the most number of patents in CPC subsection A61. In particular, they were granted 44 patents in this subsection. A61 relates to Medical or Veterinary Science and Hygiene. To get a feel for the specific types of the invention in this subsection below is a sampling of the Edwards Lifesciences patents in this section.
| 9675452 | Artificial heart valve with scalloped frame design |
| 9675453 | Methods of identifying and replacing implanted heart valves |
| 9675455 | Method of positioning a minimally-invasive heart valve with cusp positioners |
| 9693862 | Holders for prosthetic heart valves |
| 9707074 | Method for treating an aortic valve |
| 9707078 | Expansion device and method for treating vascular passageways |
| 9717591 | Prosthetic valve for replacing mitral valve |
Top Edwards Lifesciences inventors in CPC Subsection A61 are the same as the list above because Edwards focuses their patenting efforts to be narrowly tailored into their niche area of innovation.
Universal Electronics, Inc.
Universal Electronics Inc. (NASDAQ: UEIC). is a worldwide leader in universal control and sensing technologies for the smart home. They have four main innovative areas of technology: connectivity, device discovery and control, voice control and advanced navigation, and integrating smart devices into home entertainment, as shown in Table 9. According to the USPTO database, their primary area of innovation is in CPC Subsection G06 which is related to Computing; Calculating; Counting. 50% of their patents in 2017 were related to this field.
| CPC Subsection Title | Number of patents categorized in CPC section | % of the total number of patents |
| G06: Computing; Calculating; Counting | 17 | 50% |
| G08: Signalling | 8 | 24% |
| G05: Controlling; Regulating | 4 | 12% |
| None | 4 | 12 |
| G11: Information Storage | 1 | 3 |
| Grand Total: | 49 |
Table 9
On average, 1.02 inventors were listed on each patent.5 Below is a list of the most prolific inventors. The data shows that these three inventors work independently of each other.
Table 10 lists the top 3 inventors based on the number of patents for which they were included as part of the inventive entity.
| Inventor | Number of Patents |
| Paul D. Arling | 20 |
| Patrick H. Hayes | 19 |
| Arsham Hatambeiki | 12 |
Table 10
As noted above, Universal Electronics was granted the most number of patents in CPC subsection G06. In particular, they were granted 17 patents in this subsection or 50% of their patents were in this area of technology. To get a feel for the specific types of invention in this subsection below is a sampling of the Universal Electronics patents in this section.
| 9720575 | System and method for flexible configuration of a controlling device |
| 9727213 | System and method for retrieving information while commanding operation of an appliance |
| 9727234 | System and method for appliance control via a personal communication or entertainment device |
| 9733804 | User interface for a remote control application |
| 9736523 | System and method for configuration of a controlling device to enable selection of media streams |
| 9762647 | System and method for using image data in connection with configuring a universal controlling device |
| 9792133 | Interactive web-based codeset selection and development tool |
Top Universal Electronics inventors in CPC Subsection G06 are the same as the list above because it appears that the innovative engine of the company is focused on these individuals.
Innovation trends to watch – and innovation trends in Orange County
Because of the two of the top 4 most innovative companies in Orange County, California. It might also be interesting to track the number of other pharmaceutical companies that come into the local area in the future. Based on the average number of inventors on patent data, anecdotally it appears that the more successful companies have more of a collaborative environment in which R&D occurs.
I invite you to contact me with your patent questions at (949) 433-0900. Please feel free to forward this article to your friends. As an Orange County Patent Attorney, I serve Orange County, Irvine, Los Angeles, San Diego, and surrounding cities.
1. https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/orangecountycalifornia/PST045216 ↩
2. 181 total number of inventors divided by the number of patents which was 79 equals 2.3. ↩
3. 194 total number of inventors divided by the number of patents which was 83 equals 2.33. ↩
4. 122 total number of inventors divided by the number of patents which was 49 equals 2.48. ↩
5. 49 total number of inventors divided by the number of patents which was 46 equals 1.02. ↩
