A claim in a patent or patent application uses the words A, AN, THE, and SAID. This article explains how to utilize these words in a claim properly.
The basic rule for initially introducing a term
The first time that you recite a term in a claim, you must use the word A or AN to introduce that term. For example, a claim to a tripod may look like this.
A tripod for supporting a camera.
Tripod was introduced with the word A as well as the camera.
The basic rule for reusing the term
The second time that you use the term in the claim, you must use the word THE or SAID. For example, the tripod claim may look like this.
A tripod for supporting a camera, the tripod having a first leg, a second leg and a third leg to stabilize the camera.
The basic rule for using SAID
The words THE and SAID mean the same thing and are used in the same way.
Instead of using THE in the claim, you can use the word SAID. For example, the tripod claim may look like this.
A tripod for supporting a camera, said tripod having a first leg, a second leg, and a third leg to stabilize said camera.
In my opinion, the claim is easier to read if you were to use THE instead of SAID. However, some old-school patent attorneys insist on utilizing the word SAID instead of THE. You’ll often find contemporary patents and applications using the word THE instead of said because of its ease of understanding.
Purpose of the rules
The purpose of the rules is to make clear the terms you are introducing for the first time and those terms which you are reusing. For example, if the claim above were rewritten as follows, it would be confusing (i.e., indefinite).
A tripod for supporting a camera, said tripod having a first leg, a second leg and a third leg to stabilize said camera, a first leg being elongate and stiff.
This claim is unclear whether the first and second instances of the “a first leg” refer to the same “first leg.” The second instance of a first leg could be referring to some other part of the tripod that has a leg. To make clear that the second instance of the first leg refers to the first instance of the first leg, you need to change A to THE as shown below.
A tripod for supporting a camera, said tripod having a first leg, a second leg and a third leg to stabilize said camera, the first leg being elongate and stiff.
Following this structure will help you to make the claim clear. Read: Claim drafting tip: Use terms consistently
Why is the antecedent basis rule important?
Patent law requires that all terms require antecedent basis in the claims. Antecedent basis simply means that each term is introduced with the word A and can be referred to with the word THE, as discussed above.
During litigation, a defendant could avoid liability for patent infringement by arguing that the claim is not clear, or legally speaking, indefinite under 35 USC 112.